Legislature(1999 - 2000)
09/23/1999 08:40 AM House BUD
| Audio | Topic |
|---|
* first hearing in first committee of referral
+ teleconferenced
= bill was previously heard/scheduled
+ teleconferenced
= bill was previously heard/scheduled
JOINT COMMITTEE
LEGISLATIVE BUDGET AND AUDIT
September 23, 1999
8:40 A.M.
MEMBERS PRESENT
Representative Gail Phillips, Chair
Representative Con Bunde
Representative Eric Croft
Representative Gary Davis
Representative Gene Therriault
Representative Eldon Mulder (alternate)
Senator Randy Phillips, Vice Chair
Senator Al Adams
Senator Rick Halford
Senator Sean Parnell
Senator Gary Wilken
Senator Drue Pearce (alternate)
COMMITTEE CALENDAR
APPROVAL OF PREVIOUS MINUTES
August 10, 1999
REVISED PROGRAMS (RPL's)
EXECUTIVE SESSION
Preliminary Audit Reports
Final Audit Reports
AUDIT REPORTS
Release of Final Audits
Consideration of Audit Reports
OTHER COMMITTEE BUSINESS
WITNESS REGISTER
TOM MAHER, Legislative Assistant
to Representative Gail Phillips
Alaska State Legislature
Capitol Building, Room 411
Juneau, Alaska 99801
Telephone: (907) 465-6873
DAVID TEAL, Director
Division of Legislative Finance
State Office Building, Sixth Floor
Juneau, Alaska 99811
Telephone: (907) 465-3795
POSITION STATEMENT: Introduced the RPL's
PAT DAVIDSON, Director
Division of Legislative Audit
State Office Building, Sixth Floor
Juneau, Alaska 99801
Telephone: (907) 465-3830
POSITION STATEMENT: Spoke to the Audit Reports
MERLE JENSEN, Deputy Legislative Auditor
Division of Legislative Audit
State Office Building, Sixth Floor
Juneau, Alaska 99801
Telephone: (907) 465-3820
NICO BUS, Administrative Services Manager
Division of Support Services
Department of Natural Resources
400 Willoughby Avenue, 5th Floor
Juneau, Alaska 99801-1724
Telephone: (907) 465-2406
POSITION STATEMENT: Spoke to the Department RPL's
NANCY SLAGLE, Director
Division of Administrative Services
Department of Transportation and Public Facilities
3132 Channel Drive
Juneau, Alaska 99801-7898
Telephone: (907) 465-3911
POSITION STATEMENT: Spoke to RPL #25-0-6200
CAROL TAYLOR, Planner
Division of Statewide Planning
Department of Transportation and Public Facilities
3132 Channel Drive
Juneau, Alaska 99801-7898
Telephone: (907) 465-4070
POSITION STATEMENT: Spoke to RPL #25-0-6200
BARBARA RITCHIE, Deputy Attorney General
Office of the Attorney General
Department of Law
PO Box 110300
4th Floor, Dimond Courthouse
Juneau, Alaska 99811-0300
Telephone: (907) 465-2133
THOMAS DAHL, Assistant Attorney General
Human Services Section
Department of Law
PO Box 110300
5th Floor, Dimond Courthouse
Juneau, Alaska 99811-0300
(907) 465-3600
ACTION NARRATIVE
TAPE 99-6, SIDE A
CHAIR GAIL PHILLIPS called the Joint Committee on
Legislative Budget and Audit meeting to order at 8:40 A.M.
on September 23, 1999. Members present at the call to order
were Representatives Phillips, Croft, G. Davis, Therriault,
Mulder and Senators Phillips, Adams, Wilken, and Pearce.
Representative Bunde and Senators Halford and Parnell
arrived later during the meeting. (time not noted).
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
CHAIR PHILLIPS announced that the first order of business
would be the approval of minutes from the August 10th
Legislative Budget and Audit Committee meeting.
SENATOR PHILLIPS MOVED approval of the minutes and asked for
unanimous consent. There being NO OBJECTION, the minutes
were approved and adopted.
REVISED PROGRAMS (RPL's)
DAVID TEAL explained the RPL's before the Committee for
review and action.
RPL Number: 02-0-0026
Department of Administration
Senior Services BRU
Home and Community Based Care Component
$28,900 MHTAAR - Operating
DAVID TEAL explained that the funding would be used for
temporary relocation of the Bridge Adult Day Program from
the Mountain View/Juneau Senior Center to the Twisted Fish
Company Restaurant. The program, with 4-5 full time staff
and an average of 20 clients, provides a structured
therapeutic day program for frail and disabled people of any
age who have Alzheimer's Disease and related disorders.
Mr. Teal continued that the relocation is necessary due to
an Alaska Housing Finance Corporation (AHFC) initiated
remodel of the Mountain View/Juneau Senior Center. The
remodel is necessary to bring the building up to code and
that the Twisted Fish restaurant is ADA compliant.
The Mental Health Trust Authority awarded these funds on
July 15th, 1999. AHFC will be paying for all the remodeling
costs and some of the relocation costs of that project.
Catholic Community Services will be providing $11,900
dollars. The requested RPL would cover the balance of
costs.
SENATOR ADAMS MOVED to adopt the requested funding. There
being NO OBJECTION, RPL #02-0-0026 was adopted.
RPL Number: 10-0-4013
Department of Natural Resources
Information/Data Management BRU
Information Resource Management Component
$310,000 Federal - Operating
DAVID TEAL commented that the requested funds would be used
for the development of a modern digital mining claim and
land information system that includes both State and federal
mining claims, and bridges isolated land record systems.
The multiple agency systems having no electronic cross-
reference currently make it difficult to obtain information.
Statewide access to past and future mining claims and land
record databases will be improved with the new system. The
Department would be the lead agency on the project.
Mr. Teal continued, on August 14th, 1998, LBA approved RPL
10-9-4002 for $125,000 federal dollars to initiate the
project. The requested amount would supplement the original
funding.
The request was not included in the FY00 budget because at
the time, the specifics were not known. There should be
requests included in the FY01 and FY02 budgets and that
there would be no impact on general funds. Mr. Teal noted
that $150 thousand dollars of the request would be spent on
personal services (current positions). The funding will
bring the vacancy factor back down to 5.5%.
REPRESENTATIVE MULDER asked if the positions saved by the
proposed funding request would have different
responsibilities than those positions lost in the FY00
operating budget cut.
NICO BUS explained that those personnel would have been laid
off, regardless. The proposed project tries to consolidate
State and federal records. The employees would be handling
different functions by incorporating the mining claim
records, using the newly purchased equipment to make
information more readily available to the public. He
stressed that the mining community is very supportive of the
project.
SENATOR PHILLIPS questioned how the Department could justify
the request given the status of the advisory vote.
NICO BUS responded that the decision would be left to the
LBA Committee. He added that economic development takes
State financial effort to automate.
REPRESENTATIVE G. DAVIS asked if the requested positions
would be middle management hires.
SENATOR PHILLIPS interjected that a partial part of the "no"
vote was to reduce the size of government. He pointed out
that the proposed RPL was the bureaucury requesting more
positions with federal funds. He suggested that the "no"
vote should be recognized. Senator Phillips commented that
he was determined to take a more "hard line@ view of such
proposals.
REPRESENTATIVE BUNDE advised that each time the State
receives money from the federal government, the State
"suffers" by passing it. He echoed Senator Phillips
concerns.
SENATOR ADAMS commented that his interpretation of the "no"
vote was different from his colleagues. He suggested that
if Anchorage wants to have cuts, they should be given those
cuts. The rest of the State is not saying that. He
believed that the rest of the State would like to see a
different plan than that proposed in September. Senator
Adams suggested that the merits of the debate should
incorporate mining and development economic status for
Alaska.
SENATOR PHILLIPS inquired where the positions would be
located.
NICO BUS responded that they were located in Anchorage.
REPRESENTATIVE THERRIAULT asked if the funding request would
cover only the current fiscal year.
NICO BUS explained that in last year=s project, the federal
government funded $450 thousand dollars. The RPL is for
$310 thousand dollars which would be carried forward into
FY01 for $140 thousand dollars.
REPRESENTATIVE THERRIAULT asked if the federal government
had been approached after the State's operating budget was
completed.
NICO BUS replied that the Department had been working with
the mining community and the federal government for a long
time to streamline the system. The proposed RPL is the
resulting product. The federal government was not sure if
they would continue funding this project, however,
correspondence in June provided one more allocation in the
amount of $450 thousand dollars to implement the next phase.
REPRESENTATIVE MULDER questioned the length of federal
appropriation anticipated by the Department.
NICO BUS replied that the remaining $140 thousand dollars
would be carried into FY01.
REPRESENTATIVE MULDER asked if the Department anticipated
the new hired positions to be "gone" after a two-year
period.
NICO BUS responded that those positions would be gone after
completion of this specific project.
REPRESENTATIVE CROFT commented on his frustration that an
alternative had not been presented to the public for the
advisory vote. He noted that there has been a lot of "talk"
regarding resource development as a "way out" of the State's
bleak financial situation. The proposed RPL would provide a
way, without spending State general funds, to move toward
resource extraction, economic development and additional
jobs. Representative Croft acknowledged that the task of
determining the "no" vote indication would be difficult for
Alaska.
SENATOR PHILLIPS countered that part of the $100 million
dollar revenues and the proposal were part of the
conditions.
REPRESENTATIVE G. DAVIS questioned if the RPL would expand
economic development opportunities or would it add current
mining claims easier access to that information.
NICO BUS replied that it would address both the old and the
new claims.
REPRESENTATIVE BUNDE understood that the mining industry and
resource development, return approximately 20% of the actual
cost to the State, to provide this service.
NICO BUS did not believe that amount was correct. He
suggested that the impact was greater to the economy. He
offered to provide those statistics to the Committee.
REPRESENTATIVE BUNDE interjected that it was fair to assume
that there was not a net gain. He projected that the only
resource, which does not cost the State more, is oil.
NICO BUS replied that could only be determined by the
definition of "net gain". If the understanding were
employment for the Alaskan citizens, this request provides
that.
REPRESENTATIVE THERRIAULT commented that the Fairbanks North
Star Borough did an economic impact analysis and determined
that the mining industry was one of the largest property tax
payers in that borough. He emphasized the tremendous
benefit of that service to our State.
REPRESENTATIVE MULDER asked if the RPL would allow the State
to look at federal lands for potential claims.
NICO BUS replied that the State can currently do that,
however, that information is found in two different places.
The proposal would provide consolidation.
SENATOR ADAMS MOVED to adopt the requested RPL #10-0-4013.
SENATOR PHILLIPS OBJECTED.
A roll call vote was taken on the motion.
IN FAVOR: Representatives Phillips, Croft, G. Davis,
Therriault and Mulder (alternative)
Senators Adams, Wilken, Pearce (alternative)
OPPOSED: Representative Bunde
Senator Phillips
Senators Halford and Parnell were not present for the vote.
The MOTION PASSED (7-2).
RPL Number: 10-0-4014
Department of Natural Resources
Mining, Geological, Water Development BRU
Geological Development Component
$400,000 Federal - Capital
DAVID TEAL explained that the request was an amendment to an
existing capital project. The federal funds are available
from the U.S. Bureau of Land Management (BLM) to conduct an
airborne geophysical survey of parts of the Sleetmute and
Iditarod Quadrangles in southwestern Alaska. He added that
the Department would procure and manage a survey contract
according to specifics in a cooperative agreement with BLM.
The products of the survey are expected to catalyze mineral
exploration and development of the survey area.
Mr. Teal pointed out that the existing capital project for
an Airborne Geophysical and Geophysical Mineral Inventory
was initiated with $400 thousand general fund dollars during
last legislative session. BLM signed the cooperative
agreement on September 13th, 1999. The funds will expire on
October 1, 1999 if not encumbered by the State for the
project. The Department did not include the new funding in
the FY00 budget because availability was not known until
July 1, 1999.
Mr. Teal continued, the projected completion date of the
project is September 30, 2000 and there will be no impact on
the general fund. He noted that no new positions would be
requested for this project.
SENATOR PEARCE questioned if a contract already existed.
NICO BUS responded that the entire project would be contract
work for the helicopter time to fly into those areas. The
areas contracted for last session will be worked on in the
spring. He added that the work would basically be done on
federal land with federal money. The federal government has
requested that the Department administer their contract over
their land.
SENATOR PEARCE questioned if the size will expanded, would
it run as a separate contract. She asked if that would
create additional efficiency.
NICO BUS advised that efficiency exists as the Department
has run the program for the last seven years and understands
the routine. All that will be required is changing of the
actual geographic location and analysis of the data.
SENATOR PEARCE inquired who would own the data.
NICO BUS stated that the federal government owns the data,
and that it is available to the public.
SENATOR ADAMS pointed out that the area affected was that
represented by Senator Hoffman and that area has the lowest
employment in the State. Senator Adams asked why the
Sleetmute and Iditarod survey was chosen for this RPL.
NICO BUS advised that the federal government made the
choice, as it was a combination of federal and Native lands
nominated. Senator Stevens identified these areas and the
federal government put the money up front to the State of
Alaska. The State will benefit, as there are some areas
that are closely federal/State/Native lands.
REPRESENTATIVE THERRIAULT asked if the federal government
had a specific project in mind. He noted that the money
would lapse in a couple of weeks.
NICO BUS replied that he did not know the source of federal
money, but thought that there had been some year-end lapse
money made available for the project.
SENATOR PHILLIPS asked what would happen if the RPL was not
approved.
NICO BUS stated that the project would not be funded and the
federal government would receive $400 thousand dollars back.
He added that there was a $10 thousand dollar administrative
fee associated with the RPL.
SENATOR WILKEN MOVED to adopt RPL #10-0-4014.
REPRESENTATIVE BUNDE OBJECTED. He asked if these funds
would be technically counted as State spending. Mr. Bus
acknowledged they would.
REPRESENTATIVE G. DAVIS clarified that it would be a
standard land survey.
NICO BUS explained the process of picturing the land platted
areas to determine good prospects for mining development.
REPRESENTATIVE CROFT noted that the employees would not be
federal or State workers; they would all be private contract
hires. Mr. Bus agreed.
A roll call vote was taken on the motion.
IN FAVOR: Representatives Phillips, Croft, G. Davis,
Therriault, Mulder (alternate)
Senators Halford, Wilken, Adams
Pearce (alternate)
OPPOSED: Representative Bunde
Senator Phillips
Senator Parnell was not present for the vote.
The MOTION PASSED (8-2).
RPL Number: 25-0-6200
Department of Transportation and Public Facilities
AMATS Community Transportation
Cooperative Program (CTCP)
$250,000 Federal Receipts - Capital
CHAIR GAIL PHILLIPS noted that the Department had received
authorization last session to receive these funds. She
pointed out that the request came to the LBA Committee from
the urging of Senator Donley. She stressed that the RPL
does not need approval.
Chair Phillips recommended that the Committee take NO ACTION
on the request. She stated that she did not want to begin
the practice of bringing RPL's forward that does not need
the Committee's approval. It will create excess work for
the agencies and unnecessary delays. If this RPL was
approved, it would raise the question of what the Department
would use the authority for. She requested that Mr. Teal
explain the issue.
DAVID TEAL explained that the Municipality of Anchorage
applied for and has been awarded, a discretionary grant from
the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) under the
Transportation and Community System Preservation Pilot
Program. This is a planning grant with a two-tiered
approach. Tier I would re-design the Municipality's public
involvement process for the AMATS Transportation Improvement
Program. Tier II would apply the new process specifically
to a significant transportation-planning project, the Ship
Creek Multimodal Transportation Plan. The anticipated
product is a stand-alone program that the AMATS and
Municipality's Planning Department could apply to future
planning efforts for both land use and transportation
issues.
Mr. Teal continued, the funding was not anticipated during
the regular budget process. The Municipality's grant
proposal competed nationally with other states' proposals,
and was awarded from FY99 special discretionary funds. This
is a one-time request and the funds are available now.
Notification of the award was received June 18, 1999, via
signed federal aid agreement and no expenditures have yet
been made. The funds, however, must be obligated by
September 30, 1999, before the close of the federal fiscal
year. If the RPL is not approved now, the Municipality of
Anchorage will lose the grant. He added that the grant is
100% federally funded and that there are no implications for
positions, indirect cost recoveries or efficiency measures.
Mr. Teal noted the two letters distributed to Committee
members addressing the RPL. [Copies on File]. He noted
that what exists is an RPL, which the Department intended to
proceed on without a request because of broad authority in
the budget. He commented that he could not speak for the
Department, however, when money is used, not in the budget,
it removes funds from projects supposedly allocated for. He
acknowledged that one could argue that this RPL could take
from a later RPL or could provide a project that did not
come before the Committee.
SENATOR PEARCE stated that as Senator Donley had explained
it to her, there were funds that could be used to do the
project, however, there is a grant from the federal
government for $250 thousand dollars. He had intended for
the Department to get the grant for this project and keep
the original allocation in AMATS for contingency projects.
He understood that there were two different pots of money.
SENATOR HALFORD asked if there was a net increase of $250
thousand dollars would be available with the approval of the
RPL. He suggested that could create new federal money.
SENATOR PEARCE commented that the Department of
Transportation and Public Facilities was going to use $250
thousand dollars that they already had rather than taking
the federal money.
SENATOR HALFORD pointed out that given the contingency, the
Department would then have a net increase of $250 thousand
dollars.
DAVID TEAL referenced the letter, noting that no LBA meeting
had been scheduled at that time before the money needed to
be obligated. The Department wanted to proceed with the
project and felt the only way to proceed was to use existing
authority. He recommended that the Department respond to
the questions of the Committee.
CHAIR PHILLIPS reiterated that the request came directly
from Senator Donley.
SENATOR PEARCE advised that was because the Department
wanted to use the money they already had; they did not want
to put $250 thousand dollars more to the project.
DAVID TEAL informed members that he could not address the
"internal" thinking of the Department.
REPRESENTATIVE MULDER clarified that the request would be
$250 thousand additional dollars to AMATS. He asked if the
RPL was authorized, would that funding would be replacing
existing authorized funding.
SENATOR ADAMS expounded that the Anchorage community has
applied for a federal grant. The State is only a "pass
through" vehicle to give the money to that community. He
emphasized that Anchorage should have local control over
their needs.
NANCY SLAGLE stated that the request was a pass through
grant which AMATS applied for. It must go through the State
because of U.S. Department of Transportation and Public
Facilities requirements. There is a deadline on the RPL and
the Department has been working with Anchorage to make sure
that the money is available to them.
Originally, the Department did plan to use the appropriation
in the Capital Budget, an AMATS appropriation, for
contingency and cost overruns. It would fit within that
appropriation. It was Senator Donley's concern that
prompted the Department to bring the request forward to the
LBA Committee to receive additional authority. He believed
that the Department would then continue to have authority on
the books for the contingency.
SENATOR HALFORD asked if the Department supported the
concept.
NANCY SLAGLE replied that the Department could go either
way. She suggested that it would be "cleaner" if the
Committee provided the additional authority.
CAROL TAYLOR indicated that everything needed to be in place
for the grant to be received by the 1st of October, 1999.
CHAIR PHILLIPS stated that the RPL would be HELD for further
discussion.
EXECUTIVE SESSION
SENATOR PHILLIPS made a motion, in accordance with Title 24
and 44, to move to Executive Session for the purpose of
discussing audit reports, which are held confidential by
law. There being NO OBJECTION, the Committee went into
Executive Session at 9:20 A.M.
CHAIR PHILLIPS requested that Pat Davidson (Legislative
Auditor), Merle Jensen, (Deputy Legislative Auditor), David
Teal (Director of Legislative Finance Division) and Tom
Maher (Legislative Budget and Audit Committee Aide) attend
the Executive Session.
The Committee resumed open session at 9:35 A.M.
(TAPE MALFUNCTION)
AUDIT REPORTS
SENATOR ADAMS MOVED that the final audits on the agenda be
released to the public:
* State of Alaska/Single Audit for FY 1998
* DOA/DCED/ASMI/AIDEA
* DOA/Office of Public Advocacy/Public Guardian
Program
* DOC/Review of Select Internal Controls
There being NO OBJECTION, the final audits were released for
public view.
SENATOR ADAMS MOVED to release the preliminary audit report:
* DOA/Alaska Commission on Aging
There being NO OBJECTION, the preliminary audit was released
for agency response.
OTHER COMMITTEE BUSINESS
CHAIR PHILLIPS acknowledged that this might be the last
Budget and Audit Committee meeting before Merle Jensen,
Deputy Legislative Auditor, retires. Therefore, she took
the opportunity to present a plaque to Mr. Jensen. Chair
Phillips noted that Mr. Jensen had used his position to
actively promote better government and that he had been a
strong advocate of the principle that State agencies be
accountable to the public. She stated that Mr. Jensen had
well served the citizens of the State, the Legislature and
the LBA Committee. He had been deputy to five of the past
six auditors and that his services will be missed.
CHAIR PHILLIPS recommended that the Committee address the
Department of Law briefing on Superior Court order,
Kasayulie versus the State of Alaska, 9/1/99 at the
scheduled Legislative Council meeting for October 1, 1999.
SENATOR PHILLIPS pointed out that there was a representative
from the Department of Law attending the LBA meeting.
BARBARA RITCHIE advised that the Department is working on
the case. At this point in time, no final decision has been
made, however, the clock continues to tick. She explained
that there were two portions of the case, both a facility
and trust section and to date, there has been no final
judgement.
SENATOR PARNELL asked why reconsideration had not yet been
filed.
TOM DAHL replied that there had not been a motion made for
reconsideration. He acknowledged that there is a better
approach.
SENATOR ADAMS spoke to the emotional impact of the issue.
He recommended that the State begin by trying to solve some
of the inequities that already exist.
REPRESENTATIVE BUNDE advised that anytime the Courts find
that something is unconstitutional, there is usually an
appeal.
BARBARA RITCHIE stated that the findings were not taken
seriously. She reiterated that there has not yet been a
final decision.
REPRESENTATIVE MULDER supported the idea of addressing this
issue through a joint meeting scheduled with Legislative
Counsel. He acknowledged that the argument of the plaintiff
could establish the time frame.
BARBARA RITCHIE stated that the Court did have information
regarding the case for the past ten years. She recommended
that it would be better to focus on the issues rather than
the length of time involved.
Senator Pearce asked to revisit RPL #25-0-6200.
RPL Number: 25-0-6200
Department of Transportation
and Public Facilities
AMATS Community Transportation
Cooperative Program (CTCP)
$250,000 Federal Receipts - Capital
SENATOR DAVE DONLEY stated that the funding source is the
Anchorage Area contingency for Planning/Construction
shortfalls and Road/Intersection Improvement. He noted that
he supported additional federal authorization to fund the
grant, however, acknowledged the possibility of finding STIP
or TIP monies.
(TAPE RECOVERY)
REPRESENTATIVE MULDER asked if the money would "go away" if
the RPL were not awarded.
SENATOR DONLEY understood from reading the Department's back
up that there is a time limit in which the money would need
to be locked in. He believed that date was September 30th.
NANCY SLAGLE stated that the grant monies would not be
available if not obligated by the end of the month. She
pointed out that if the Department does not receive approval
for additional receipt and expenditure authority or approval
to use the contingency appropriation for this purpose, there
is a possibility of loosing that money.
CHAIR PHILLIPS questioned what the recourse would have been
if a LBA Committee meeting had not been scheduled at this
time.
NANCY SLAGLE replied that the Department would have used the
contingency funding.
REPRESENTATIVE MULDER asked if the $250 thousand dollars
would then "go away".
NANCY SLAGLE understood that the grant money had to be
obligated.
CHAIR PHILLIPS believed that the approval had already been
granted to the Department in last year's budget. She
reiterated her concern with bringing this RPL before the
Committee for action.
SENATOR PEARCE asked how the Department could use
contingency money that was approved as part of AMATS for a
project that was not listed on the STIP or the TIP.
NANCY SLAGLE replied that if the Department could not
receive specific authority, they would have to rely on this
money. It is a fairly broad appropriation, the contingency
appropriation, in that it was not an appropriation that was
requested by the Department but rather included by the
Legislature. The Department had not received specific back-
up to indicate the breadth of the size and the
appropriation. She reiterated that it is a very broad
appropriation. The Department felt that with the
information that they had, it could be accommodated.
SENATOR PEARCE asked if the Department had been given
specific direction before the Governor vetoed the Intent
Language.
NANCY SLAGLE stated that she did not believe that there was
Intent Language that was written specifically to that
appropriation.
REPRESENTATIVE THERRIAULT noted that this project had not
been approved. He warned that the Department was attempting
to "slide" the project in under a broad interpretation. He
reiterated that it was not approved and that this money was
new.
Representative Therriault believed that it was appropriate
that the LBA Committee make the decision at this time
whether to approve these funds.
A roll call vote was taken on the motion to approve RPL #25-
0-6200.
IN FAVOR: Representatives Croft, G. Davis
Mulder (alternate)
Senators Parnell, Wilken, Adams, Halford
OPPOSED: Representatives Phillips, Therriault, Bunde
Senators Phillips
The MOTION PASSED (6-4).
ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 10:05 A.M.
| Document Name | Date/Time | Subjects |
|---|